T

Logic Puzzles & Deduction

Maths · Y4 OC Prep
Year 4 OC
Lesson Guide
Explanation
Deduction is clue-squeezing: each clue eliminates suspects until one remains. 'Two digits, even, more than 40, digits add to 7.' Start with the SHARPEST clue — digits adding to 7 gives a short list (16, 25, 34, 43, 52, 61, 70…). Now filter: even kills 25, 43, 61; more than 40 kills 16, 34. Survivors: 52 and 70. But 7+0=7 ✓, even ✓, >40 ✓ — two survivors?! Recheck… 70 works too unless another clue splits them. Real tests make clues airtight — and YOU must test every clue against your answer.
Your Turn
'Odd, between 30 and 50, digits add to 9.' Who am I? Check: 39 (3+9=12 ✗)… 45 ✓ odd? No! 45 is odd ✓ → 45.
Watch Out
An answer must satisfy EVERY clue, not most. Test all clues at the end — one forgotten clue is the classic slip.
Explanation
Who-owns-what puzzles beg for a grid: people down the side, pets across the top. Read each clue and mark: 'Ana's pet swims' → Ana gets a ✓ under fish — and instantly ✗s fill the rest of her row AND the fish column (one pet each!). 'Ben is allergic to feathers' → ✗ under bird for Ben; with fish gone, Ben must have the cat. Cara inherits the bird. The grid's power: every ✓ triggers a cascade of ✗s.
Your Turn
Three kids — Ed, Fay, Gus — play soccer, chess, tennis. Ed hates running; Fay beat the chess champion. Who plays what? Check: Ed chess, Fay soccer or tennis… Fay is not chess; Ed = chess; Gus and Fay split soccer/tennis — need one more clue! (Notice when clues are not enough.)
Watch Out
Only mark what a clue PROVES. "Fay beat the chess champion" means Fay is NOT the champion — it does not say what she plays.
Explanation
'Largest possible' puzzles reward a scoring habit. OC flavour: digit cards drawn with straight lines — pick two cards to maximise right angles. Don't eyeball a pair: SCORE each card first (the 4 has 3 right angles, 5 has 4, 6 has 4), THEN pick the top two: 5 and 6 give 8. The same score-then-choose routine wins 'smallest possible', 'closest to 100' and every other optimisation puzzle.
Your Turn
From digits 3, 6, 8, pick two to make the largest 2-digit number, then the smallest. Check: 86 and 36.
Watch Out
'Two DIFFERENT cards' — constraints like different/adjacent/at most sneak into these puzzles. Circle them.
Explanation
A signature OC format: three statements, and you pick which are correct. OC style: counters 1–15, one taken at random. 'Even and odd equally likely' — COUNT: eight odds (1, 3, 5, 7, 9, 11, 13, 15), seven evens — false! 'More likely above 8 than below 8' — count: seven each (9–15 vs 1–7) — equal, so false. 'A 4 as likely as a 13' — one counter each — true. The method: judge each statement with an actual COUNT, separately, never by gut feel. Then match your verdicts to the answer options.
Your Turn
Counters 1–14: is "odd and even equally likely" true now? Check: 7 odds, 7 evens — TRUE for 1–14 (15 was the troublemaker!).
Watch Out
The statements are designed so your instinct says true. Counting takes ten seconds and is never wrong.
Explanation
When a puzzle asks 'how many ways', list like a robot: fix the first choice, run through every second choice in order, then advance the first choice. Two-digit numbers from 2, 5, 7: the 2-family (22, 25, 27), the 5-family, the 7-family — nine, provably. Random listing skips some and repeats others; robot listing does neither. This is also the fallback when magic-shape puzzles resist the clever trick: systematic trial beats scattered guessing. Quiz and exercises now!
Your Turn
How many 2-digit numbers from 3, 8 with NO repeats? List them! Check: 38, 83 — just 2.
Watch Out
Read whether repeats are allowed — it changes 9 ways into 6. The words 'different digits' are load-bearing.
Step 1: Introduction
Step 1 of 5
Every clue removes suspects 🔍 "I am a 2-digit number. I am even. I am more than 40. My digits add to 7. Who am I?" 2-digit + even + >40 → 42, 44, 46, …, 98 (lots!) digits add to 7 → 42? 4+2=6 ✗ · 52? 7 ✓ but odd… wait — 52 IS even ✓ answer: 52 (5 + 2 = 7, even, more than 40) ✓ Method: apply the SHARPEST clue first to shrink the list fast, then test survivors against every remaining clue.
The elimination grid 🐱 cat 🐟 fish 🐦 bird Ana ✗✓✗ Ben ✓✗✗ Cara ✗✗✓ Clues: "Ben is allergic to feathers. Ana's pet swims." Ana = fish (swims). Ben ≠ bird → with fish taken, Ben = cat. Cara gets the bird. Every ✓ fills a row AND a column with ✗s!
OC flavour: right angles in digit cards 4 3 right angles 5 4 right angles 6 4 right angles "Pick TWO different cards — largest possible number of right angles?" Strategy: count each card's value FIRST, then pick the two biggest. 5 has 4, 6 has 4, 4 has 3 → best pair: 5 and 6 → 8 right angles. 'Largest possible' = score every option, then choose. Never guess-pick.
OC format: which statements are correct? A bag holds counters numbered 1 to 15. One is taken at random. 1: "Even and odd are equally likely." ✗ — 1-15 has 8 odds but only 7 evens! 2: "A number bigger than 8 is more likely than one less than 8." ✗ wait — 9-15 is 7 numbers, 1-7 is 7 numbers… EQUAL. ✗ 3: "Taking a 4 is as likely as taking a 13." ✓ — one counter each: equally likely. Judge EACH statement separately with a count — never by feel.
List like a robot 🤖 "How many 2-digit numbers can you make from 2, 5, 7 (repeats allowed)?" 22 25 27 52 55 57 72 75 77 9 numbers — and the ordered list PROVES it. Robot rules for listing: 1. Fix the first digit, run through all second digits. 2. Move to the next first digit. Repeat. Ordered lists cannot miss and cannot repeat. Random lists do both.
Was this lesson helpful? Rate this Course
Discussion
Loading comments...